This paper examines how private landlords approach asset selection in the Scottish private rented sector (PRS), exploring how they identify available properties, narrow their choices and undertake property appraisals. It is the sister publication to an article published at the start of 2026 on landlord asset allocation which can be found here.
The research reveals that landlords adopt differing but patterned approaches to narrowing their choice frame. Initial preferences concerning investment returns, property location, target markets served, and property type impose constraints that progressively narrow the field of options. The paper conceptualises this process as “path-dependent frame contraction”.
Approaches to property appraisal also varied considerably, although most included financial and physical appraisal components.
The findings demonstrate that landlords exhibit both rational maximising and bounded rational satisficing behaviours, with investment decisions influenced by heuristics, cognitive biases, previous experience, personal preferences, gut feel and pragmatism.
Importantly, these decisions do not simply determine the performance of individual investments. They ultimately influence the number, type, size, condition and location of properties in the PRS and, by extension, the markets and tenant groups served or excluded by the sector.
The paper provides the first empirical examination of landlord asset selection through the combined lenses of behavioural finance and normative investment theory. It highlights opportunities for policymakers to better understand landlord investment behaviours and apply behavioural tools and policy instruments to encourage more balanced investment patterns in the PRS.
